Imagine a world without America...

Reacties

#93449

Mike

 

Britain wouldn't exist without America either.

#46815

Rick

 

Wisdom comes with the years, I guess.

The USA as a country clearly isn't around long enough to get it.
Yes, US of A, you 'control' the world. So what? Europe did too, right around when you guys were a colony and way before that. At a certain point we learned and said fuck it, and gave all colonies the right to govern their own, as they deserved.

Meanwhile, you became the new bully, still trying to make new colonies up to this day. What did/does it bring you?

One day you'll learn.

#37040

Karl

 

Shouldn't they have added: provide the solution, then create the problem. Surely applicable to a lot of the items...

#36766

gadzooks

 

These little hubristic exercises of juvenile pleasures extolling the touch and sensation . Ooh its good ! I must be good ! . Perhaps it is and if your lucky you may find an adult to get you a paper and pencil to chart the dead from sea to shining sea to shining sea . America and Americans are so deceived by the concentrations of wealth which intrude in lawless contradictions when -Money- not America is challenged . These generational piles of money which demand that before one little girl is vaccinated or one treaty is honored that the hegemony of old money command the colours of the sky or irrational power equal to irrational demands . Your country , Our privilege . It is not America but the power of great wealth which distorts opportunity and sanctions . Massive drumbeats of death to advance perceived advantages . The trouble with that is as with any old and reactionary structure , they are not reacting to the present situations . So the great learning experience is on the backs of the defenseless , which turns out to be cheaper than thinking or a possessing a conscience . Just a bit of a drag for the survivors of the juvenile masters of power , us the defenseless .

#36502

sankulot

 

"undercooled" ??
are you playing with our feet ?

#36311

ivan janssens

 

Natives killed by Europeans? Ok, but then:

"George Washington, in 1779, instructed Major General John Sullivan to attack the Iroquois and "lay waste all the settlements around... that the country may not be merely overrun but destroyed," urging the general not to "listen to any overture of peace before the total ruin of their settlements is effected." Sullivan did as instructed... "

And Thomas Jefferson:

"instructed his Secretary of War that any Indians who resisted American expansion into their lands must be met with "the hatchet." "And... if ever we are constrained to lift the hatchet against any tribe," he wrote, "we will never lay it down till that tribe is exterminated, or driven beyond the Mississippi," continuing: "in war, they will kill some of us; we shall destroy all of them." [...] Indeed, Jefferson's writings on Indians are filled with the straightforward assertion that the natives are to be given a simple choice - to be "extirpate[d] from the earth" or to remove themselves out of the Americans' way."

The hard fact is that the extiction of the indians continued long after the Unites States was born. This also is the U.S as we know it.

#36294

R.W.

 

You know this is very much like the Colbert Report. Only without the sweet sweet irony. Like this entire site. It is like Bill O'Reilly is trapped in some weird e-crazed Flemish Borms wannabe. And it is even more entertaining how some of these other folks think that if you're against the United States (America still stays a continent) you must be a) terrorist or b) a communist, my personal view, as shared by Prof Noam Chomsky and Prof Howard Zinn, is that you're just not deprived of rational thought.

#36273

traveller

 

@ pvc

This is to easy. The natives were killed by europeans who were in the process of conquering a new continent in their old-fashioned style. This was not yet the U.S. as we know it.
The civil war is the feudal South(european style) against the industrial North.
The major growing problems of the U.S. were imported european problems which the founding fathers solved by their marvellous Constitution, but it took time to take root.

#36271

Stijn

 

A world without France would mean the US wouldn't exist and we wouldn't have to watch shitty Youtube crap like this.

#36239

pvc

 

america can stay and even the americans, but put a good government there, that would help a lot...

@traveller: o yes, the americans where very friendly for their natives and there were no civil wars. Violence is inherent in man, not in ethnicity or immigrant status.

#36227

traveller

 

@ RP

Thanks for the information, I don't believe the figure as such, no matter where it comes from because of the misinformation worldwide.
The U.S. was much more tolerant before in the big cities and they were obliged to apply zero-tolerance in the big cities.
My personal experience is that violent crime in the U.S. is ghetto- and immigrant-related, something we are learning here now in Europe.

#36221

RP

 

@ traveller
http://www.homeoffice.gov.u...

And apart from the fact that I agree that the figures for some countries are a mere estimate, my point is that in a country that values personal freedom so much, it doesn't take a whole lot to end up behind bars.

#36219

traveller

 

@RP

Where did you get this figure of 23%. Do you know the prison population of India, China, Pakistan, Bangla Desh, Russia???
There is not one single correct figure about the prisonpopulation of those countries.

#36218

Joe

 

@Luc: "Magnificent, undercooled tongue-in-cheek humor!"

Are you sure it came from herself and not from an unemployed PG Wodehouse-epigone?

#36213

RP

 

Ah yes, the land of the free. Now home to 23 % of the world's prison population.

#36197

Peter Fleming

 

@Ivan: and Al got an Oscar for it, can you believe it?!

#36193

Barton

 

This is the worst advertisement I've ever seen!

#36187

ivan janssens

 

I agree with Btb here. This is on a level with an Al Gore movie.

#36181

BtB

 

Someone should market this as a self-help video: "How to prove you are a sorry lot of humourless sods who lack historical insight."

Seriously, in trying to prove a point, they make a joke of themselves. It pains me to see how reasonably intelligent people (it's not thát easy to master Windows Movie Maker) actually believe this sort of falsifying a-historical crap.

#36177

LVB

 

Maggie no humor?

"You turn if you want to. The lady's not for turning".

And recently, when here bronze statue was unveiled: "I would have preferred iron, but bronze will do".

Magnificent, undercooled tongue-in-cheek humor!

#36175

Cogito

 

Ah I understand.
You may be right on the humourlessness, but what 's the relevance?

Like Maggie. She didn't have so much humour either but she did save the economy and the Falklands.
Reagan on the other hand did it much the way Maggie did, only with humour. Certainly not worse, but not necessarily better.

Why is "their analysis" stupid? (stoopid sounds black to me, not?)

#36172

Joe

 

my point was that these people have no humour and their analysis is stoopid.

#36164

Cogito

 

Go on Joe, make your own movie(s):
Imagine a world without the soviet union
Imagine a world without Castro
Imagine a world without Arabia
Imagine a world without China
eh eh
Imagine a world without France
uh I (what is verslikken in English?) myself in my laughing...

#36162

Joe

 

One thing is sure: these people who made this have the wrong sense of humour and are just... wrong :-) Flush it!

#36160

Cogito

 

America is the one main thing that prevented George Orwell's book to come true in 1984.

#36150

VI

 

We would all pay 80% taxes, have no tv, only nobles would drive cars, we would all wear lederhosen, probably no electricity but we'll have electricity bills from the state-controlled monopolist, japan would be the same as mongolia, no elevators, main communication channel would be the 'pigeonnet' and we would have this conversation in german or russian at the steel factory while being drunk.

#36142

traveller

 

A world without America would be a world with Stalins, Maos, Hitlers, colonial empires and no cradle of freedom

#36139

Wouter

 

Wat een ongelofelijke egotrippers zijn die Amerikanen toch.

#36136

Steven Tijpels

 

Yet a world with more nuclear fallout hanging over the continent, shortly after the eradication.

#36134

De advocaat des duivels

 

En een oorlog met veel minder geweld, oorlog en CO2 uitstoot! ;-)